Pickerel Lake

Pickerel Lake, Michigan Real Estate

Pickerel Lake is the quiet headwater of the Inland Waterway, small, clean, and calm. Linked to neighboring Crooked Lake, it is one of the cleaner lakes in the Petoskey area and suits buyers who want a low-key setting close to town.

Be the First to Know About New Pickerel Lake Homes

Stay ahead with real-time updates — no searching required.

See Homes Before Everyone Else

Why Pickerel Lake

Pickerel Lake is the quiet headwater of the Inland Waterway, small, clean, and calm. Linked to neighboring Crooked Lake, it is one of the cleaner lakes in the Petoskey area and suits buyers who want a low-key setting close to town.

Quiet Days, Water Sports and the Waterway

Days here are quiet, but the lake is deep enough for water sports, so tubes, wakeboards, and water skis are a common sight alongside the paddlers. From Pickerel a boater can pass into Crooked Lake and on down the waterway, and nature preserves along the shore keep much of it undeveloped.

What Homes Cost on Pickerel Lake

Frontage is limited and valued for privacy and clear water, so supply stays low. Homes range from modest cottages to well-kept year-round residences. Listings are few and often sell before they are widely seen, so the Hartwicks keep close watch and help buyers act quickly when the right property comes up. Thinking of selling here? See how the Hartwicks help you sell your home with confidence.

Nearby: Crooked Lake and Burt Lake on the Inland Waterway, with Petoskey for town.

Quiet-Water Picks on Pickerel Lake

Quiet-water picks: paddling and boating some of the cleanest water on the waterway; the connection to Crooked Lake and the full Inland Route; the Ponshewaing and Alanson nature preserves; quiet fishing; and easy access to Petoskey and Harbor Springs.

Questions Buyers Ask About Pickerel Lake

What Buyers Want to KnowWhat Pickerel is like, Pickerel against Crooked, why listings are few, water skiing, and the case for an inland lakeView QuestionsClose▾
What is Pickerel Lake like?▾

Small, clean and calm, the quiet headwater of the Inland Waterway. It links to neighbouring Crooked Lake and is one of the cleaner lakes in the Petoskey area. Nature preserves along the shore keep much of it undeveloped, and the overall feel is low-key rather than resort.

How does Pickerel Lake compare with Crooked Lake?▾

They connect by a short channel, so a boat can move between them, but they feel different. Crooked is the larger and busier of the two, with villages on its shore and the main run down to the rest of the Inland Waterway. Pickerel is smaller, deeper, clearer and quieter, with preserved land along much of its edge and far fewer homes. Buyers who want the waterway with a lively shore usually land on Crooked; buyers who want the waterway and still water in the evening usually land here, if they can find frontage.

Why are there so few listings?▾

Because there is very little frontage and the people who hold it tend to keep it. Listings are few and often sell before they are widely seen. Buyers who are serious about Pickerel generally need to be watching continuously rather than checking in occasionally, and ready to move when something appears.

Can you water ski on Pickerel Lake?▾

Yes. Days here are quiet, but the lake is deep enough for water sports, so tubes, wakeboards and skis are a common sight alongside the paddlers. From Pickerel a boat can pass into Crooked Lake and on down the full Inland Route.

What are the advantages of buying a home on an inland lake in Northern Michigan?▾

Northern Michigan’s inland lakes are one of the region’s best-kept real estate values. While marquee lakes like Walloon Lake, Torch Lake, Lake Charlevoix, Lake Michigan, Burt Lake, and Mullet Lake command premium prices and limited inventory, the area’s smaller inland lakes — including Crooked Lake, Pickerel Lake, Round Lake, and others — offer waterfront living at a fraction of the cost, often with more homes available and less competition among buyers.

The lifestyle on an inland lake is appealing in its own right. Many of these lakes are quieter, with less boat traffic and a more secluded feel — ideal for families, retirees, or anyone looking for a true cottage retreat. Swimming, kayaking, fishing, and pontoon boating are all part of daily life, and some inland lakes offer excellent fishing that the larger, busier lakes can’t match. Properties on these lakes often come with larger lots, mature tree cover, and the kind of privacy that’s increasingly hard to find on the bigger waters.

From a value perspective, buyers who are flexible on which lake they call home can get significantly more house — and more waterfront — for their dollar on an inland lake. The Hartwicks know these lakes firsthand and can match buyers with the right fit based on budget, preferred activities, and how much solitude or community they’re after. For many of their customers, discovering the inland lakes is what turns a vacation home dream into a reality.

Newest Homes for Sale in Pickerel Lake, Petoskey, MI

9669 Trails End Road, Petoskey
$1,750,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 479905 MLS
A sandy beach and room to expand on the Inland Waterway? Yes, please! Life on Pickerel Lake is about making the most of every season, and this exceptional property delivers. Set on three separate parcels totaling over two acres with 107 feet of beautiful sandy frontage and deep water on the Inland Waterway, it offers the Up North lifestyle families dream about. The additional rear parcels create a rare opportunity for future expansion, with the potential to build additional homes, a guest house, or another garage or outbuilding. Summer days begin with coffee overlooking the lake and end with sunset cruises, while afternoons are spent boating the Inland Waterway, swimming from the sandy shoreline, kayaking quiet coves, or entertaining on the deck, covered patios, walkways, and inviting outdoor gathering spaces. The sunroom creates a seamless connection between indoor comfort and the beauty of the lake beyond. A large pole building and separate lakeside utility building with changing space, storage, and an outdoor shower provide outstanding flexibility for hobbies, guests, and effortless lake living. Located just minutes from Petoskey, you'll enjoy easy access to waterfront dining, boutique shopping, golf, skiing, and everything Northern Michigan has to offer. Whether you're watching the fall colors reflect on the water, gathering with family for summer weekends, or relaxing by the fire after a day on the lake, this is a property designed for creating memories that will last for generations.

9669 Trails End Road, Petoskey

Start Your Search

IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use, it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. © 2026 NM-MLSX.

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!