Explore Lake Michigan, MI Homes for Sale Between $2,500,000 to $3,000,000

All Lake Michigan, MI Homes for Sale Between $2,500,000 to $3,000,000

$4,950,000
7 Beds 4 Baths 479683 MLS
Situated along the north shore of Little Traverse Bay on Lake Michigan in the prestigious Forest Beach Association just 2 miles from Harbor Springs, 5087 Forest Beach Drive offers a rare opportunity to own a charming, historic, beachfront family cottage. Situated on one full lot plus two additional half lots, the property boasts 150+ feet of private sandy frontage just steps from the cottage. The main residence, originally built in the 1880s, has been lovingly held in the same family since 1923, preserving its history and character through 6 generations. With five bedrooms and three full baths, the home offers generous space for family and guests and is well-suited for year-round use. At the heart of this beadboard walled cottage is a beautiful stone fireplace, anchoring the main living space with warmth and timeless appeal. An additional inviting feature includes a front porch with a NanaWall system which consists of foldable glass walls along its perimeter. They can be opened or closed depending upon weather. The porch turns into a heated glassed-in family room during the cold months. The kitchen features an iconic AGA range with convection ovens, ideal for both everyday meals and entertaining. Central air conditioning and a whole-house Generac generator provide modern comfort and reliability throughout the year. Complementing the main home is a newer carriage house and garage built in 2008. The structure includes a two-car garage with a workshop and hobby/exercise room overlooking the lake, plus a spacious upper-level apartment with two bedrooms, one bath, and a loft—perfect for family or houseguests. Blending historic legacy, thoughtful updates, and an unmatched beachfront setting, this cottage is a truly special retreat designed for making memories across all seasons. Showings by appointment only with proof of funds or lender pre-approval. $20,000 transfer fee to join FBA. Garage apartment is rented for the summer and cannot be shown.

5087 Forest Beach Drive, Harbor Springs

$3,900,000
7 Beds 6 Baths 479495 MLS
Set within The Preserve at Bay Harbor, one of Northern Michigan's most private and sought-after gated communities, this exceptional estate sits on 125 feet of deeded Lake Michigan shoreline with direct beach access steps from the walkout lower level. Water views greet you from the primary suite's private balcony each morning, and by evening the great room's two-story windows catch the last light fading across the lake behind the quartzite fireplace. This is a home that was built to be full of life. The island kitchen opens to the main floor living space with the kind of easy flow that makes a dinner for twenty feel no different than a quiet Sunday morning for two. A fully outfitted butler's pantry handles the behind-the-scenes work of hosting, and a second kitchen on the lower level adds the depth that long summer weeks and holiday gatherings require. Dedicated laundry on the main and lower levels, along with dishwashers on both, mean that the logistics of an extended stay simply disappear into the background. The primary suite offers dual walk-in closets, a generous bath with a soaking tub and walk-in tile shower. Upstairs and on the walkout lower level, additional bedroom suites and flexible living areas give every guest their own space to settle into. Patios and balconies on each level keep the lake present throughout the day and well into the evening. Beyond the gates, the Village of Bay Harbor and all it offers is just minutes away, from world-class golf and dining to the marina and the energy of a community that draws people back summer after summer. This is the kind of property that becomes the gathering place for generations. Seller is a licensed Realtor in the State of Michigan.

6804 Preserve Drive, Bay Harbor

$8,900,000
6 Beds 10 Baths 479194 MLS
From the brick pavers to the gas lanterns to the graduated slate roof, 6028 Trillium Trail will transport you to a grand European estate. Inspired by the English Arts & Crafts style of Sir Edwin Lutyens from the late 19th-early 20th centuries, the custom bricks laid with varying patterns around the windows. Upon entering, you are met with the great room featuring 300-year-old wormy chestnut floors from Europe, extensive Lake Michigan views, and with a 13th century fireplace. A large deck wraps around the lake side of the house, this will be your favorite place on warm summer days. Gather in the kitchen around the Aga stove and custom copper hood. The copper sinks pair nicely with the black Vermont soapstone counters. The stone floor was salvaged from streets in Jerusalem. The home has old world wet plaster walls, warmed with in-floor heat, and cooled with geothermal ac through hidden vents. The other six fireplaces are carved Indiana limestone, each with its own special design. The south west facing primary bedroom is bathed in sunlight with a stunning view of Lake Michigan towards Charlevoix. The ensuite bath features blue granite slabs, marble brick tiles, and sterling silver fixtures. The two floor library is encased in warm knotty pine with floor-to-ceiling bookcases. Climb the beautifully crafted spiral staircase to the fourth floor office. The woodwork throughout the home are rich mahogany. On the second floor are a guest bedroom and a bunk room, both with ensuites, a second primary bedroom, currently an office & sitting room, with one of the most spectacular bathrooms in the house, and a full guest suite with its own staircase, kitchen, and living room. Play billiards with friends in the lower level, watch a movie in the media room, and serve drinks from the bar and wine cellar. There is another guest bedroom on this level, as well as a sauna, gym, and access to the lower deck. Lose yourself in the sparkling blue waters and spectacular Lake Michigan sunsets.

6028 Trillium Trail, Harbor Springs

$4,150,000
5 Beds 5 Baths 477607 MLS
Commanding more than 26 acres above Lake Michigan, this Harbor Springs estate combines panoramic views of Little Traverse Bay with a premier location along M-119. With over 636 feet along M-119, at the entrance to the famed Tunnel of Trees - and the Little Traverse Wheelway bike path passing directly by—the property is as connected as it is private, minutes from downtown yet surrounded by rolling landscape and mature hardwoods. At the heart of the estate, a residence designed by Nick White and crafted by Behan Construction draws the bay into nearly every room. The main level centers on a spacious kitchen with custom cabinetry, granite flooring, island, breakfast nook, and wet bar, opening to a dining area framed by windows and a welcoming sitting room with fireplace. Also on this level, the primary suite offers sweeping water views, a walk-in closet, and a spa-like ensuite, while an attached three-car garage provides everyday ease. Upstairs, three bedrooms - including both jack-and-jill and private ensuite layouts - ensure space and comfort. The finished walkout lower level extends living outdoors with patio access and a new composite deck above, while a flexible room can serve as a study or additional bedroom. Meticulous landscaping grounds the home in its setting, where every vantage point captures a new perspective of the bay. As part of the offering, a separate two-bedroom, one-bath guest cottage is included - an understated complement to this remarkable estate. Unmatched in scale, location, and views, 731 W Hathaway Road is a rare opportunity to own one of Northern Michigan’s most distinctive properties.

731 W Hathaway Road, Harbor Springs

$3,450,000
5 Beds 5 Baths 477593 MLS
A long, winding drive delivers you to a private retreat where Lake Michigan views set the backdrop for everyday living. Surrounded by mature trees and thoughtful landscaping, this home balances seclusion with convenience - offering the peace of 9 acre estate setting while being only minutes from downtown Harbor Springs and Petoskey. From nearly every room, sweeping views of Little Traverse Bay create a sense of calm and connection to the water rarely found at this scale. Inside, custom design by Nick White and craftsmanship by Behan Construction blend comfort and elegance. The main level features a dining room framed by bay views, a welcoming sitting room with fireplace, and a spacious kitchen with granite flooring, custom cabinetry, island, breakfast nook, and wet bar - designed as much for gathering as for cooking. The primary suite offers a private sanctuary with expansive water views, a walk-in closet, and a well-appointed ensuite. Upstairs, three additional bedrooms include a jack-and-jill layout plus a private ensuite, ensuring space and privacy throughout. Multiple living areas extend outdoors, from a new composite deck overlooking the bay to a finished walkout lower level with patio access. Whether working quietly in the study or entertaining on the back deck, every corner of this property is intentional and inviting. An attached three-car garage, meticulous landscaping, and proximity to beaches, dining, and year-round recreation complete the offering. 731 W Hathaway Road is more than a home - it’s a place where Northern Michigan luxury meets comfort, privacy, and connection to the bay.

731 W Hathaway Road, Harbor Springs

$4,390,000
5 Beds 8 Baths 476048 MLS
Last opportunity for a luxury home in the desirable Sunset Ridge neighborhood, offering panoramic views of Little Traverse Bay! Boasting over 6,000 sq.ft. of luxurious living space, this home features 5 bedrooms, 5 full baths, and 3 half baths, blending refined elegance with unparalleled comfort. Designed by architect Alex Bogaerts, every aspect has been thought out with premium finishes, from stunning stone accents to the spacious open-concept layout ideal for seamless living and entertaining. The chef-inspired kitchen is a true highlight, equipped with custom cabinetry, a large island, a six-burner Wolf gas range, Sub-Zero refrigerator, two Cove dishwashers, Wolf wine refrigerator, and a butler’s pantry featuring a built-in Wolf coffee maker, Sub-Zero beverage cooler and ice maker, all flowing effortlessly into the formal dining room. The great room showcases a striking natural gas fireplace, adding warmth and charm. Step outside to the expansive 1,400 sq.ft. deck, perfect for hosting guests while enjoying the breathtaking bay views. The luxurious master suite offers a private deck, a spa-like bath with a tile shower, a soaker tub, vanity and dual walk-in custom closets, creating a true retreat. The main level also includes two half baths, a laundry room with an LG washer and dryer, and an office, providing both convenience and functionality. Above the 3 car garage, the unfinished bonus room offers versatile options, whether as a playroom, media room, or bunk room. The lower level is designed for ultimate entertainment, featuring a spacious family room with a gas fireplace, a kitchenette, a guest suite, three ensuite bedrooms, a half bath, additional laundry room with a stackable LG washer and dryer, and a stone patio. This home is also pre-wired for blinds, surround sound, and security cameras. The beautifully landscaped grounds, framed by mature trees, provide a private, serene atmosphere.

4712 Sunset View Lane, Petoskey

$3,295,000
6 Beds 8 Baths 474294 MLS
Rising above Little Traverse Bay, The Summit Over Bay Harbor offers a rare opportunity to create a bespoke waterfront residence in one of Northern Michigan’s most prestigious resort settings. Designed for those who value elevated living, privacy, and unforgettable surroundings, each residence captures sweeping water views and dramatic sunsets from multiple levels. This expansive offering features approximately 5,586 square feet of interior living space, complemented by a 1,139 square foot rooftop terrace designed for entertaining, relaxation, and evening gatherings overlooking Lake Michigan. An additional 720 square feet of unfinished lower-level space provides flexibility for storage or future customization, bringing the total square footage to approximately 7,445 square feet. Floor-to-ceiling windows flood the interiors with natural light and frame the bay as a living work of art. The open main living level is ideal for hosting, anchored by a gourmet kitchen with premium appliances, generous island, fireplace, wet bar, and seamless indoor-outdoor flow. The primary suite is a serene retreat with panoramic water views, private patio access, a spacious walk-in closet, and spa-inspired bath. Multiple en-suite bedrooms, each with private outdoor access, provide exceptional comfort and privacy for family and guests. A detached guest house and four-car garage further enhance the residence, while elevator access connects each level with ease. Residences at The Summit Over Bay Harbor are offered as custom build opportunities, allowing buyers to select architectural details, interior finishes, and premium upgrades tailored to their lifestyle. Located across from The Cliffs at Bay Harbor and minutes from Petoskey, Charlevoix, Boyne City, and Harbor Springs, this is Northern Michigan luxury living at its finest.

3575 Charlevoix Avenue Unit #14, Petoskey

Start Your Search

IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use, it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. © 2026 NM-MLSX.